Asia/ Time to talk: The stark reality of suicide"MANILA--The World Health Organization's first conference on Suicide Prevention in the Western Pacific, held here in mid-August, drew delegates from 20 countries.
Each had a similar message: The suicide rate in their countries is rising-often alarmingly.
The issue is still taboo in some Asian countries and many have yet to even compile suicide statistics. Japan, on the other hand, has been dealing with the problem for years.
However, alarm bells began to sound in 1998, when the number of suicides in Japan jumped by 8,000 over the previous year.
Every year for the past seven years, in excess of 30,000 Japanese have taken their lives.
Experts are now warning that other nations in Asia, South Korea in particular, are headed down the same track.
According to Seo Dongwoo, a researcher from the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, the number of South Korean suicides hit the 10,000-mark for the first time in 2003, with 10,932, the highest number on record.
"It is as if South Korea is becoming like Japan, especially during its period following the early 1990s, when Japan's asset-inflated economy collapsed," he told the conference.
In 1997, South Korea was pummeled by the Asian financial crisis. Many companies went under. The country's gross domestic product nose-dived, from 7 percent in 1996 to minus 6.9 percent in 1998.
Meanwhile, the number of suicides skyrocketed to 8,569 in 1998 from 6,022 the previous year.
Although suicides fell to below 7,000 in 2000, as the economy started to recover, the figure started growing again in 2001 in tandem with accumulated debt held by households.
Seo points the finger almost exclusively at economic recession, citing figures that show men in their 40s are most likely to kill themselves.
In 2003, he said, 2,257 men in that category took their lives.
The country is now trying to work out ways of bringing down the suicide rate. For example, people with mental health problems are being urged to see doctors at regular intervals. Whether this and other measures will have any effect remains to be seen.
China reported a drop in the suicide rate from 18.30 per 100,000 people in 1998 to 14.55 in 2002. However, it does not compile country-wide suicide statistics, so the figures are only rough estimates.
Nevertheless, they reveal disturbing trends.
Chinese experts told the 46 government officials, researchers and psychiatrists gathered at the conference the suicide rate in rural areas is triple that of urban areas, which suggests low-income levels are largely to blame.
Even more alarming is the number of young women who take their lives, the experts said.
Figures show that men are more likely to commit suicide than women. But in rural China, the number of suicides by women in their 20s is estimated to be double that of their male peers. By method, 58 percent of suicides in rural residents were accomplished by swallowing agricultural chemicals. This compares to just 2 percent in Japan.
Hong Kong researchers said, meanwhile, that the preferred method of suicide was to jump from a tall building, of which the former British colony has many.
Singapore is faring relatively better than its Asian neighbors, as evidenced by its 2001 suicide rate of 9.2 per 100,000. But for women aged 15 to 24, the rate is higher than the world average.
In Micronesia, said a government official, a total of 1,087 suicides were reported to the government in the 40-year period up to 1999.
Generational clashes between "parents who cherish their traditional culture and children who adore Western culture" were cited as a key motive for suicides in the Western Pacific island group.
While all acknowledge the frightening statistics, experts say little can be done in the way of prevention without greater knowledge of the task at hand.
Of the 20 participating countries and regions, only a handful of countries and regions, including Japan, South Korea, New Zealand and Hong Kong, keep national statistics on suicides.
Many lack even the most basic necessity-manpower.
Cambodia, for example, has only 26 psychiatrists, and although that is far more than the two left practising in 1975, it is clearly not nearly enough.
The country is also facing a huge shortage of researchers to gather and analyze suicide data, an official said.
The situation is similar in Mongolia.
A researcher provided the conference with suicide data from only one hospital in Ulan Bator. It was the only information available, he said.
Culture, experts agreed, poses yet another barrier.
Due to mainly religious reasons, Malaysia and Singapore still view suicide as a criminal act, while in the Mariana Islands, suicide is considered a "disgrace," and is, therefore, an issue that is clouded in secrecy..."
... "Also on the table for discussion was the media's role in easing the soaring suicide rates, with some pointing to reports showing cases in which suicides were prompted by media reports.
Yoshitomo Takahashi, a professor of behavioral science at the National Defense Medical College, said that after popular Japanese singers killed themselves, it was not unheard of for fans to also end their lives.
"The media should refrain from sensational coverage of suicides and from reporting suicide methods in detail (to avoid copycat suicides). The media's cooperation and understanding is vital,'' said Takahashi.
A researcher from South Korea echoed Takahashi's remarks, saying the media can play a major role.
Citing a recent case in which a famous actress killed herself, he said media reports highlighted the fact that the woman, afraid of leaving herself open to prejudice, had stopped receiving treatment for depression. Had she continued seeing doctors, she may have overcome her suicidal tendencies, the researcher said.
Explaining cases such as this in the media could help ease misconceptions on mental health.
He said the media's role was so important in this regard that an academic society for suicide prevention had started handing out special awards to media companies that are sensitive in their reporting of suicides.."
International Herald Tribune/Asahi: October 1,2005