To: Mr. John Proudman
From: Thomas Blackacre, Esq.
Re: Proposed Production Project in Japan
Date: April 2, 1994
_____________________________________________________________
Attached is the final letter of intent (Memorandum
of Understanding) with Muttsubishi Corporation as executed as
of April 1, 1994. You will note that while the Memorandum of Understanding
covers many of the important points regarding the establishment
of our Asian production base (e.g., form, territories, ownership
and committed technologies), a number of issues remain pending
with Muttsubishi. Notable among these are royalty pricing, management
structure, termination conditions and various technical issues
such as dispute resolution. Set forth below are the positions
you have indicated that senior USM management should seek during
the actual Joint Venture negotiations later this week in Tokyo.
Management Structure | We must keep close watch over the management of the Joint Venture. Consequently, we would prefer a board of directors of 8 persons (4 from MC and 4 from USM). We would like a USM expatriate to hold the legal position of Representative Director and the official position of Chairman or President. We also wish to have USM expatriates hold the positions of Vice President-Finance and Vice-President-Operations. | |
Japan Sales Royalty for USM technology | We want a 6% of net sales royalty on products incorporating USM technology but are willing to accept 4% if Muttsubishi can produce results. | |
Sales Royalty on Asian sales incorporating USM technology | We would like to see a 6% of net sales royalty on products incorporating USM manufacturing technology but we should be flexible based on market needs. | |
CLASI Technology Royalty | We want a royalty of 7 or 8% of net sales and certainly not lower than 5% of net sales of Products incorporating this technology. | |
ACE Technology
Royalty | We are willing to pay up to 6% of net sales for this technology but would like to pay less. | |
Financing | Our cost of funds from our United States banks for the ¥2,500 billion portion of the Joint Venture loan is 120 basis points over the Yen long term prime rate. The maximum maturity such banks would lend to us is 10 years. We would like to obtain a longer term (20 years if possible) and a lower spread. | |
Rental Rate | Our sources suggest that factory land in the Yokosuka-Zushi area is currently renting for between ¥8,000 and ¥14,000 per tsubo and that the MC land is well situated. We would like a rental rate as near to ¥8,000 as possible since rent payments will take funds out of the Joint Venture (another source of return to MC on this Joint Venture). |
Of course, there are a variety of other
issues which may need to be resolved during the Joint Venture
negotiations and these should be taken up after the above primary
issues are resolved in the first negotiating session.
I am distributing a copy of this Memorandum
to the negotiators for their reference.
-End-