Media specialists hurt Dentsu
in Asia
by David KilburnSince Asia's economic crisis began in Thailand mid-2006, events in
Thailand have often proved a forerunner of those elsewhere.
Last year, budget cuts on caused total Thai advertising billings to fall by 8 percent to
38 billion Baht, according to Advertising Association of Thailand. The Association also
reckoned that around 20 percent of Thailand's 250 advertising agencies closed down last
year.
For the survivors, it is not business as usual. Recession has dealt a sharp blow to the
concept of traditional "full service" agencies. Many Thai advertisers are
looking to reduce advertising costs by turning both to independent media houses, where
commissions may be 3-4%,( compared with 15-17.65% traditionally charged by agencies), and
to low cost creative or production boutiques to churn out the ads. MindShare, Zenith,
Starcom and the like have helped Western agencies respond quickly to change.
And now it is Dentsu's turn to respond. Seventh-ranked Dentsu (Thailand) is now seeking a
partner to set up a media company. According to interviews with Dentsu Thailand's
president Kazuhiro Nobuta, the initiative is the first step in a longer term plan by the
agency to overhaul its entire billing structure, and move towards a fee-based system of
payment. The move was prompted by the growing number of cash-strapped companies in
Thailand rejecting traditional agency commission levels. "We are re-appraising our
business and are looking for strategic partners who have the same working chemistry to
survive this situation. It is now very difficult. If the industry doesn't move to a
different system, 50 per cent of all agencies in Bangkok will collapse," Nobuta
reportedly said.
While unwilling to show its hand, a spokesman for Dentsu in Tokyo conceded that "some
of the Dentsu agencies in Asia are studying possible counter measures to protect
themselves against the inroads being made by media companies penetrating their business in
each market." "This, therefore, means more than just the feasibility of setting
up media companies. This is also not just about Dentsu (Thailand)," added the
spokesman, declining to elaborate further.
Of course it need not have worked out like this. For much of 1998, Dentsu was talking to
Tempus about the possibilities of the two working together in Asia. According to one
source familiar with the talks, an Asian business model could have been developed from
CIA's partnership with CDP in the UK, with CIA providing media services to a number of
Dentsu agencies. Those plans however foundered when Tempus made it clear they would also
with to open in Japan. Working closely, on a network basis, with an independent media
company was also a worrying idea to some Dentsu executives who hesitated at the idea of
'outsiders' becoming privy to Dentsu's workings on such a broad scale.
While boosting critical mass, working with local partners in a number of countries is
hardly likely to improve Dentsu's grasp of modern media planning technologies, the service
Western agencies have rapidly rolled out across Asia. Though the planning penny has yet to
drop, Dentsu nonetheless is steadily becoming a stronger competitor for international
agencies in Asia. Last year, for the second year in succession, Dentsu emerges as the top
agency in Taiwan.
|
Published in Marking Week in
March 1999 |